Stifel Access has been replaced by Stifel Wealth Tracker.
Get your full financial picture and organize your financial life, with Stifel Wealth Tracker.
Click here to sign up. 

Happy Couple on Beach

Retirement Plans Comparison Chart

Scroll to the right to see full chart –>

PLAN TYPES: SEP IRA SIMPLE IRA PROFIT SHARING 401(k) 401(k) "SAFE HARBOR 403(b) DEFINED BENEFIT
PROVISIONS:
Target Employer:
Small employers, including non-profits 100 or fewer employees and maintains no other plan  All, including non-profits  All, including non-profits, but excluding government entities All, including non-profits, but excluding government entities  Public education institutions, churches, and nonprofit groups under IRC 501(c)3  All, including non-profits
Eligible Employees: Employed for 3 of last 5 years, earned $600 in current year, and age 21 or older. Can exclude certain union and nonresident alien employees.

Can’t exclude part-timers.
Earned $5,000 during any two preceding years and expected to earn $5,000 in current year.

Can exclude certain union employees and non-resident aliens. 
One year of service, 1,000 hours, age 21 or older.

Can exclude certain union employees and non-resident aliens. 
One year of service, 1,000 hours, age 21 or older.

Can exclude certain union employees and non-resident aliens. 
One year of service, 1,000 hours, age 21 or older.

Can exclude certain union employees and non-resident aliens. 
All employees except non-resident alien, student employees, employees who work < 20 hours/week, or employees who defer < $200/year.  One year of service, 1,000 hours, age 21 or older.

Can exclude certain union employees and non-resident aliens. 
Total Maximum Annual Contribution: $58,000 per person  $27,000 per person, or $33,000 if 50 or older $58,000 per person  $58,000 per person + catch-up $58,000 per person + catch-up $58,000 per person + catch-up Amount required to fund a benefit up to $230,000/year
Maximum Employer Deductible Contribution: 25% of compensation Either 2% of compensation to all eligible employees, OR match 100% of the deferral amount up to 3%1 of compensation 25% of eligible compensation  25% of eligible compensation  25% of eligible compensation 25% of eligible compensation Amount required to fund a benefit up to $230,000/year 
Maximum Pre-Tax Employee Deferral: Not available  $13,500, or $16,500 if 50 or older Not available $19,500, or $26,000 if 50 or older  $19,500, or $26,000 if 50 or older $19,500, or $26,000 if 50 or older; 15 years of service catch-up also available Not available
Required Employer Contribution: None, unless plan is top-heavy  Either 2% of compensation to all eligible employees, OR match 100% of the deferral amount up to 3%of compensation None, unless plan is top-heavy None, unless plan is top-heavy Either 3% of compensation to all eligible employees, OR match 100% of the deferral amount up to 3% of compensation and 50% on deferrals of the next 2% of compensation None Yes
Vesting Schedule: 100% immediate 100% immediate Vesting schedules available Vesting schedules available 100% immediate vesting on safe harbor contribution; can apply vesting to other employer contributions Vesting schedules available Vesting schedules available
Testing Required: Top-heavy - Yes
ADP - No
415 - Yes
Top-heavy - No
ADP - No
415 - No
Top-heavy - Yes
ADP - No
415 - Yes
Top-heavy - Yes
ADP - Yes
415 - Yes
Top-heavy - Yes
ADP - exempt
415 - Yes
Top-heavy - No
ADP - No; ACP - Yes
Church & Gov’t plans exempt
415 - Yes
Top-heavy - Yes
ADP - Yes, if deferrrals
415 - Yes 
Distributions Controlled By: Employee Employee Employer Employer Employer Employer Employer
Participant Loans: No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Establishment Deadline: Tax-filing deadline, including extensions October 1 Tax-filing deadline, including extensions2 Tax-filing deadline, including extensions2 October 1 Last day of plan year Last day of plan year
Funding Deadline for Employer Deduction: Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions Tax-filing deadline, including extensions
5500 Filing: No No Yes, for plans with employees or greater than $250,000 Yes, for plans with employees or greater than $250,000 Yes, for plans with employees or greater than $250,000 Yes, for ERISA plans only. Yes, for plans with employees or greater than $250,000
Annual Fees: $10-$40 custodial fee per account $10-$40 custodial fee per account Administration and recordkeeping fees Administration and recordkeeping fees Administration and recordkeeping fees Administration and recordkeeping fees Actuary required

Highest administration fees



1
May reduce match to 2% or 1% of compensation in two out of five years.

2 Plan will need to be established before year-end to make elective deferrals.

1020.3304558.1